O’Neill v. Ross, 250 Mass. 92 (1924)

O’Neill v. Ross, 250 Mass. 92 (1924)

“It is the duty of the court to be solicitous at all times to guard against improper arguments to the jury. In appropriate instances undue zeal of a member of the bar in behalf of a particular client ought to be curbed by calling his attention to departures from proper evidence founded upon the evidence. . . . It is [the judge’s] primary obligation to see that a fair trial is had and that no undue advantage is taken by either side. Obviously, it is not the province of the court to confine arguments to a particular line of thoughtor within too narrow limits.”
    • Related Articles

    • Commonwealth v. Kenney, 449 Mass. 840 (2007)

      “We have previously examined the phrase "depiction by computer," as set forth in G.L. c. 272, § 29C, to determine whether evidence of child pornography stored in the form of data contained in an unopened file on a hard drive sufficed to convict a ...
    • Commonwealth v. Haas, 373 Mass. 545 (1977)

      “’Great latitude should be permitted to counsel in argument.’ Commonwealth v. Pettie, 363 Mass. 836, 840 (1973). Nevertheless, final arguments cannot be freewheeling, extemporaneous, verbal slugfests. Lawyers shall not and must not misstate ...
    • Hamilton v. Inhabitants of Heath, 246 Mass. 335 (1923)

      “So far as the photographs showed the precise place of the accident, they were admissible in the discretion of the court. Everson v. Casualty Co. of America, 208 Mass. 214 , 219-221.”
    • Commonwealth v. Lamrini, 392 Mass. 427

      In analyzing a claim of improper argument, the prosecutor's remarks must be viewed in light of the "entire argument, as well as in light of the judge's instruction to the jury and the evidence at trial." Commonwealth v. Bourgeois, 391 Mass. 869, 885 ...
    • Kelly v. Kelly, 50 Mass.App.Ct. 1101 (2000)

       Generally, a party may not present an argument on appeal that has not been presented in the trial court. White v. White,  40 Mass.App.Ct. 132, 133 (1996); Liacos, Massachusetts Evidence §3.8.1 (7th ed. 1999) ("Failure  to object to offered evidence ...